PDF

Synergy in Herbal Medicines

Abstract

In the following paper, we will review the available literature on synergy and additive effects involving medicinal herbs and herbal extracts. Several types of synergistic interactions are discussed, including apparently inactive constituents enhancing the effects of apparently active constituents within and between herbal medicines, various herbal compounds altering the absorption of others, reduction in toxicity of some herbal constituents by others, and direct synergistic therapeutic effects when active constituents are combined within and between many medicinal herbs. Species discussed include Artemisia annua (sweet Annie, qīng hāo), Ammi visnaga (khella), Glycyrrhiza glabra (licorice), G. uralensis (Chinese licorice, gān cǎo), Panax ginseng (Asian ginseng, rén shēn), Mahonia aquifolium (Oregon grape), Berberis aetnensis (Mt. Etna barberry), B. trifoliolata (algerita), B. fendleri (Colorado barberry), and Coptis chinensis (goldthread, huáng lián).

Medicinal plants contains hundreds if not thousands of unique compounds. Models based on single molecular entities do not accurately describe or capture the complexity of interactions among the constituents in medicine plants and multiconstituent extracts made from them.

In the mainstream pharmaceutical view, there is a single active constituent in a plant that explains its activity and which can be isolated and used as a conventional drug. This idea is reinforced by the fact that many widely-used drugs are either single molecules isolated from plants or semisynthetic variants of natural molecules.1,2 However, this still does not prove that the single compounds are superior to complex mixtures, particularly when possible beneficial effects of various compounds that indirectly support the main desired action have not been assessed.

In many studies, an assay (such as receptor activation or inhibition, or killing of a microbe or cancer cell in vitro) can be used to identify a single molecule or several molecules that appear to provide most or all the effect of a crude plant extract for that assay. For example, one fractionation assay ultimately determined that berberine was the single most active antimalarial constituent found in 14 different Vietnamese medicinal plants.3 This would seem on the face of it to support the conventional pharmacological model for medicinal plants. However, these assays do not evaluate the complex activities of other compounds in the plant that could directly affect the outcome being assessed. This can lead to severe oversights and a failure to recognize “inactive” constituents as providing important functions. As cited below in depth, flavonoids found in the same plant as berberine have been shown to inhibit resistance to berberine in microbes. Thus, while berberine may be the most important antimicrobial, removing the flavonoids could result in microbial resistance developing toward berberine and its failure as an antimicrobial. Activity-guided modeling misses the benefit of other plant constituents on the overall outcome, as well as other outcomes not being assessed.

This article will review the evidence on synergy of multiple compounds in complex herbal extracts, including those involving multiple herbs. Many instances are reviewed where various types of synergy have been studied with both supportive and some negative results. The term synergy will be used loosely in this review to include effects greater than the sum of the parts (true synergy) and simple additive effects. Overall, however, the current research on many important medicinal herbs underappreciates the value of complex mixtures compared with single isolated constituents.4

The prolific and widespread weed Artemisia annua (sweet Annie, qīng hāo) illustrates the problem of activity-guided research overlooking useful effects beyond the “active” constituents. The sesquiterpene lactone artemisinin (Figure 1) from A. annua is a potent antimalarial schizonticide.5 Artemisinin (qinghaosu in Chinese) and various semisynthetic derivatives of it are among the most widely-used antiplasmodial drugs in the world. It seems to be largely assumed in mainstream medicine that this is the beginning and ending of the sweet Annie story: artemisinin is the silver bullet, and there is nothing else worth investigating further in the herb. However, a clinical trial showing a crude decoction of A. annua that effectively eliminated symptoms and dramatically lowered parasite burden in adults in the Democratic Republic of the Congo with chronic malaria, with cure rates on average of 74%, despite providing far lower levels of artemisinin than are used as an isolated drugs, suggesting that there is more to A. annua than just artemisinin.6

Polymethoxylated flavonoids in A. annua also have physiological activity (Table 1), though they are supposedly not directly antiplasmodial (note that at least one in vitro study did find artemetin directly antiplasmodial).24 These flavonoids have been shown to decrease resistance of Plasmodium spp. to artemisinin by inhibiting efflux pumps in the parasite.25 Chrysosplenol D (see Figure 1), chrysosplenitin, circilineol, casticin, and artemetin have all been shown to significantly lower (by 20%–50% depending on the compound) the half minimal inhibitory concentration (IC50) of artemisinin against Plasmodium spp. in vitro.26,27 These flavonoids did not reduce Plasmodium resistance to chloroquine.26,27

Table 1:Select other actions reported for polymethoxylated flavonoids found in Artemisia annua.

Flavonoid Action Model References
Chrysosplenol D Antioxidant In vitro Xie et al., 20147
α-Glucosidase inhibitor In vitro Ezzat and Salama, 20148
Antiangiogenic In vitro Zhu et al., 20139
Casticin Antiangiogenic In vitro Zhu et al., 20139
Growth inhibition by mitotic spindle disruption Cervical cancer cells in vitro Kobayakawa et al., 200410
Antineoplastic and pro-apoptotic by many mechanisms Breast, ovarian, lung, colon, liver cancer cells in vitro Liu et al., 201411; Jiang et al., 201312; Ono et al., 200213; Yang et al., 201114
Inhibit prolactin secretion by inhibiting ERα and stimulating ERβ Metoclopramide-treated rats Ye et al., 201015
Co-stimulates IL-1β secretion In vitro Toll-like receptor 2-activated cells Lim et al., 201316
Cyclooxygenase-2 inhibition, iNOS inhibition, NF-κB inhibition In vitro Liou et al., 201417
Lipoxygenase inhibition In vitro Choudhary et al., 200918
Artemetin Lipoxygenase inhibition In vitro Choudhary et al., 200918
Anti-inflammatory Carageenan-induced edema in rat paws Sertié et al., 199019
Antibacterial against Gram positive bacteria In vitro Michielin et al., 200920
Angiotensin converting enzyme inhibition In vitro; normotensive rats de Souza et al., 201121
Hepatoprotective Carbon tetrachloride-treated rats Sridevi et al., 201222
Antiperoxidative In vitro Dugas et al., 200023

Figure 1:Artemisinin and chrysosplenol D.

While artemisinin is readily and stably extracted by aqueous decoction, flavonoids are best extracted by alcohol.28 This is interesting in light of in vitro evidence that only ethanolic and not aqueous crude extracts of A. annua are antiplasmodial, and an absence of evidence of synergy in A. annua aqueous extracts in vitro.29,30 It is also confusing given the human research on aqueous infusions of A. annua which shows they are effective.6 It should be noted that traditional methods of preparation of A. annua in Chinese medicine by soaking combined with wringing or pounding followed by juicing lead to extracts with 20 times higher levels of artemisinin than just infusion.31 Artemisinin content alone did not explain the antimalarial activity of these traditional juiced extracts in vitro; the IC50 concentrations were up to 18 times lower for the crude juices than pure artemisinin. One mouse study found that a crude ethanol extract of A. annua had a median effective dose (ED50) of 35 mg/kg vs. 122 mg/kg for pure artemisinin.32 Short-term (3 day) use of this product in an open human trial was as effective, if not more so, than chloroquine, though only 217 mg of artemisinin were delivered over the total treatment period, but had a high recrudescence rate (recurrent disease due to incomplete parasite killing). Recrudescence was lowered by extending duration of treatment or combining the A. annua capsule with primaquine.32

An in vitro analysis found that A. annua infusion with very low artemisinin concentrations (0.18% dry weight) was equally active against chloroquine-resistant and -sensitive strains of P. falciparum as pure artemisinin.33 The authors speculated these results are due either to the presence of other antiplasmodial compounds or other synergistic effects.33 Presumably these are compounds other than the polymethoxylated flavonoids given the low solubility of such flavonoids in water. Ongoing work is needed to identify all the synergistic compounds in A. annua.

Other compounds in A. annua have activities that may enhance its clinical utility for people with malaria and other conditions beyond direct antimalarial activity. For instance, a mixture of many sesquiterpene lactones from A. annua besides artemisinin showed promising analgesic activity in rodents.34 Qinghao acid, a sesquiterpene precursor to artemisinin in A. annua, and the coumarin scopoletin were shown to contribute to the bacteriostatic and inflammation-modulating effects of A. annua in another report.35 Cinnamic acid derivatives (rosmarinic and chlorogenic acids in particular) from A. annua inhibited the pro-inflammatory cytokines IL-6 and -8 in vitro.36

Polymethoxylated flavonoids from A. annua reduce resistance to other natural antimicrobials. Combining chrysosplenol D or chrysosplenetin from A. annua with subinhibitory concentrations of the isoquinoline alkaloid berberine was effective in killing Staphylococcus aureusin vitro.37 Both flavonoids by themselves had minimal direct antibacterial activity. This suggests another kind of synergy: that which occurs when multiple herbs are mixed together. Such formulation is a common practice in most systems of herbal medicine around the world and it has been suggested that various other natural antimalarials should be combined and tested in humans.38 Other herbal mixtures have been shown to have synergy against malaria in vitro.39 Other examples of formulation synergy are presented elsewhere in this paper.

There is evidence of two types of synergy in the native Mediterranean medicinal plant Ammi visnaga (khella). First, there is evidence of improved absorption of furanocoumarins from crude extracts than when they are given in isolation. Second, there is evidence of activity from other constituents in the plant besides furanocoumarins, and these other compounds enhance the activity of furanocoumarins.

The most well-known spasmolytic furanocoumarin of Ammi visnaga is called khellin (Figure 2). Khellin is absorbed more rapidly and completely when administered as part of a whole Ammi visnaga extract than when given in isolation.40 Another important furanocoumarin in Ammi visnaga, visnagin (see Figure 2), has also been shown to have its absorption significantly enhanced when administered to 12 male Sprague-Dawley rats as a whole plant extract compared with a pure compound, with a ten-fold increase in area under the curve in serum visnagin levels at the lowest dose tested (containing 0.625 mg visnagin/ml extract) of the extract compared to pure visnagin.41 This difference was highly statistically significant (P = 0.005). Equal concentrations of visnagin were administered in both forms.

Figure 2:Khellin and visnagin.

Whole extracts of Ammi visnaga were more effective at inhibiting the mutagenicity of 2-aminoanthracene, 1-nitropyrene, and daunomycin than isolated khellin in vitro.42 The identity of other constituents that were synergistic in this model were not identified. In male Sprague-Dawley rats (n=8 per group) with hyperoxaluria induced by injection of ethylene glycol and ammonium chloride, a crude aqueous extract of Ammi visnaga fruits, but not isolated khellin or visnagin, reduced urine oxalate levels compared with untreated controls (P<0.01).43 The crude extract and isolated khellin and visnagin all reduced calcium oxalate crystal deposition compared with untreated controls (P<0.05). However, the crude extract also increased urinary citrate levels while decreasing urine oxalate excretion, but the isolated constituents did not have these effects. In vitro, an aqueous Ammi visnaga extract was superior to khellin or visnagin alone at protecting renal epithelial cells from lysis due to calcium oxalate.44 These results mostly suggest other compounds in Ammi visnaga are active with different and beneficial additive or synergistic effects besides khellin or visnagin.

The European/Central Asian Glycyrrhiza glabra (licorice) and its close cousin from China, G. uralensis (gān cǎo, Chinese licorice), are two of the most important and widely used herbs in the world. One of their major uses, particularly in Chinese medicine, is to act as a corrective assistant, meaning to decrease the toxicity of other herbs with which they are combined. This is an intriguing type of formulation synergy that deserves further research, though several examples can be cited involving G. uralensis.

A classic example of this corrective assistant effect is pairing G. uralensis with Aconitum spp. (aconite, fù zǐ) prepared lateral roots to prevent cardiotoxicity. One in vitro study using rat cardiomyocytes found that G. uralensis prevented the tendency of Aconitum to increase pulse frequency of the cells, and also inhibited the increase in lactate dehydrogenase induced by Aconitum.45 Adding Zingiber officinale (ginger) rhizome extract to these two herbs further enhances the protective effect of G. uralensis. This creates a formula known in traditional Chinese medicine as sì nì tāng or “frigid extremities decoction,” first described in the Shāng Hán Lùn (Discussion of Cold Damage) from circa 220 CE that is actually cardioprotective.4648 Another observation is that Aconitum by itself induced cytochrome 3A4 in Sprague-Dawley rats (n=3), resulting in a significantly decreased absorption of buspirone, with the area under the curve of the drug reduced by 52.8% (P=0.02).49 This effect was eliminated when G. uralensis was added to Aconitum. One possible mechanism for protection against the toxicity of Aconitum is by increasing the rate of metabolism of the potentially toxic alkaloids by G. uralensis.50

There are clear chemical differences between isolated extracts of Aconitum and a combination of G. uralensis and Aconitum, suggesting that the protective effect of G. uralensis begins during preparation and is not only due to pharmacologic effects.51,52 There is also evidence of pharmacokinetic changes in Aconitum alkaloids such as hypoaconitine when taken in combination with G. uralensis and Zingiber that could explain some of the protective effects of this formulation.53

Another example of the corrective assistant effect of G. uralensis is that it decreases hepatonephrotoxicity of Dioscorea bulbifera (huáng yào zǐ, air potato) tuber. When the two are boiled together, the resulting mixture has lower levels of toxic compounds.54 Even better documented is both the reduction of toxicity of the highly toxic immunosuppressive herb Tripterygium wilfordii (thunder duke vine, léi gōng téng) decorticated root and potentiation of its antiarthritic effects in a randomized clinical trial by the addition of G. uralensis, compared with T. wilfordii alone.55 Although this trial was not blinded, it still provides supporting evidence for of this type of formulation synergy.

G. glabra and G. uralensis contain triterpenoid saponins, notably glycyrrhizin (Figure 3). It is believed that these constituents are the chemical basis for the historical use of these herbs as solubilizing agents in herbal formulas to increase absorption of other constituents, an important and distinctive synergistic feature of herbal medicine. This property is referred to as a guiding action in traditional Chinese medicine, and G. uralensis is the king of guide herbs. It appears in 50% of the 283 formulas in one of the most important materia medica of Chinese medicine, the Shén Nóng Běn Cǎo Jīng (Divine Husbandman’s Classic of the Materia Medica), compiled between 300 BCE and 200 CE.56

Figure 3:Glycyrrhizin.

In one in vitro study, adding glycyrrhizin to an aqueous solution increased the solubility of saikosaponin A from Bupleurum falcatum (thorowax, chái hú) from 0.1 mg/mL to 5 mg/mL at standard temperature and pressure.57 Saponins from other plants have this same solubilizing effect. In the same study, ginsenoside Ro from Panax ginseng (Asian ginseng, rén shēn) increased the solubility of saikosaponin A in water from 0.1 mg/mL to 3.4 mg/mL. A combination of ginsenoside Ro and the dammarane saponins of 20(S)-protopanaxadiol from P. ginseng were more effective than ginsenoside Ro by itself at solubilizing multiple saikosaponins in another in vitro study.58 Many other studies confirm the solubilizing properties of ginsenoside Ro, which may in part explain its extremely widespread incorporation into traditional Chinese herbal formulas; a similar explanation for the widespread incorporation of G. uralensis in such formulas is also likely.5961

Another mechanism whereby G. uralensis (and likely other saponin-rich herbs) can increase absorption of various other herbal compounds is by inhibition of P-glycoprotein (Pgp, also known as multidrug resistance protein 1, or MDR1) in the intestines. Pgp is a common efflux pump responsible for removal of a number of drugs and herbal compounds from intestinal epithelial cells, thus preventing their absorption. Glycyrrhizin significantly enhanced oral absorption of aconitine (AUC of aconitine increased 61% with glycyrrhizin, P<0.01 compared with aconitine alone) from Aconitum through inhibition of Pgp in male Sprague-Dawley rats (n=5).62 Other licorice compounds such as licochalcone A (Figure 4) also inhibit Pgp.63 This is a clinical concern given the potential toxicity of aconitine, but may be reconciled given all the other information reviewed above about how G. uralensis offsets the toxicity of Aconitum. Note that this property of G. uralensis has been leveraged to reduce drug resistance and amplify the utility of various antimicrobial drugs.64 The licorice flavonoid glabridin (see Figure 4) is itself a Pgp substrate and thus a competitive inhibitor of Pgp, based on a study looking at absorption of digoxin, another Pgp substrate.65 Another study found that G. uralensis decoction in vitro had no effect on Pgp, but after oral ingestion by Wistar rats (n=3) it mildly increased absorption of rhodamine 123 (P<0.05 compared with controls) and thus confirming a mild Pgp inhibitory effect.66 This study suggests some process occurred during digestion that activated compounds in the decoction.66 Other saponin-rich herbs such as P. ginseng have also been shown to be Pgp inhibitors.67

Figure 4:Licochalcone A and glabridin.

In combination with at least two herbs, crude Chinese licorice (using the alternative species Glycyrrhiza inflata) extracts have been shown to synergistically inhibit Pgp in vitro in the case of Daphne genkwa (genkwa, yuán huā) and in Wistar rats in the case of the endangered species Euphorbia kansui (kan-sui, gān suì).68,69 Both herbs are powerful cathartic laxatives and the authors of these studies commented that the synergistic inhibition of Pgp by these herbs could actually increase the toxicity of these herbs by keeping the laxative compounds in the gut longer allowing them to act more potently. Both herbs are among the very few that are traditionally regarded as becoming more toxic in combination with licorice, a type of toxic synergy. There is other evidence that G. uralensis enhances the extraction of potentially toxic diterpenoids and other terpenoids from E. kansui and this might mediate the enhancement of its toxicity.70 Whatever the mechanism, these herbs should not be combined.

Whole root aqueous extracts of G. glabra have been shown to result in lower and more delayed absorption of glycyrrhizin (described below) and its aglycone glycyrrhetinic acid, and thus to lower toxicity of the crude extract compared with glycyrrhizin given in isolation.71,72 Unidentified lipophilic constituents appear to be responsible for the effect of the whole root extract on glycyrrhizin pharmacokinetics.

There are many other aspects of synergy in licorice and G. uralensis. Table 2 lists a selection of many other intriguing reports in this vein, including at least one negative report.

Table 2:Other reports of synergy in Glycyrrhiza spp.

Comparators Model Result References
Liquiritin apioside, liquiritin, liquiritigenin, or all three combined Capsaicin-induced cough in guinea pigs Combination inhibited cough significantly more than any compound in isolation Kamei et al., 200573
Glycyrrhizin, glycyrrhetinic acids, licorice extract Multiple in vitro mutagenicity assays All were antimutagenic but licorice extract had broadest effects Zani et al., 199374
Various flavonoids and chalcones, G. uralensis extract Granulomatous inflammation in rodents Isoliquiritin many times more potent inhibitor than whole root extract Kobayashi et al., 199575
Glycyrrhizin, 18β-glycyrrhetinic acid (18BGA), aqueous licorice extract Respiratory syncytial virus inhibition in vitro Aqueous extract and 18BGA very active while isolated glycyrrhizin inactive Feng Yeh et al., 201376

Berberine (Figure 5), an isoquinoline alkaloid, is traditionally regarded as the active constituent from the roots of Mahonia aquifolium (Oregon grape) and the many species in the genus Berberis. However, multiple alkaloids are found in these species and multiple studies have found crude extracts of the roots from various species more effective than isolated alkaloids. Furthermore, non-alkaloid compounds, including those found in the leaves, have been shown to reduce bacterial resistance to the alkaloids, suggesting a potential type of synergy between different parts of the same medicinal plant.

Figure 5:Berberine.

Methyoxylated flavonolignans such as 5′-methoxyhydnocarpin (Figure 6) primarily found in the leaves of M. aquifolium (Figure 7) with no intrinsic antistaphylococcal activity have been shown to enhance this activity in berberine from roots of the plant through inhibition of the NorA efflux pump in Staphylococcus aureus.77 Another compound found in M. aquifolium leaves, pheophorbide A (Figure 8), a natural degradation product of chlorophyll, was also a strong resistance pump inhibitor in S. aureus, greatly magnifying the antibacterial activity of berberine in vitro.78 The flavonolignan silymarin from Silybum marianum (milk thistle) seed was also very active as a resistance pump inhibitor enhancing the efficacy of berberine in this study.

Figure 6:5′-Methoxyhydnocarpin.

Figure 7:Mahonia aquifolium leaves.

Figure 8:Pheophorbide A.

B. trifoliolata (algerita) leaf also contains 5′-methoxyhydnocarpin and B. fendleri (Colorado barberry) leaf also contains pheophorbide A with drug efflux pump-inhibitor effects in S. aureus.79B. aetnensis (Mt. Etna barberry) has also been shown to contain similar pump inhibitors in its leaves as that of M. aquifolium and to also inhibit the efflux of ciprofloxacin from drug-resistant S. aureus, thereby enhancing the efficacy of the drug.80 This research suggests that combining some fruit or leaf of M. aquifolium with the root would optimize efficacy, at least when treating patients with staphylococcal infections.

A crude ethanol extract of B. vulgaris (barberry) was more effective than isolated alkaloids or alkaloid fractions in rodent models of acute and chronic inflammation.81 A crude methanol extract of the root of B. aetnensis was more active against Candida albicans and other pathogenic species of Candida in vitro than an alkaloid fraction or pure berberine.82 These findings suggest a need for human research on the synergistic effects of not only whole root extracts, but also root/leaf extracts of Berberis and Mahonia spp.

Another berberine-containing medicinal species studied for synergistic properties that is frequently used in Chinese medicine, is Coptis chinensis (goldthread, huáng lián) rhizome. Total extracts of the rhizome are more active hypoglycemics than an alkaloid-only fraction of C. chinensis.83 A combination of four C. chinensis alkaloids (berberine, coptisine, palmatine, and epiberberine) were more hypoglycemic and less toxic to liver cells than berberine by itself.84,85 An alkaloid-enriched extract of C. chinensis killed 100% of male and female Kunming mice (n=20) at a dose of 0.28 g/kg; no mice were killed by a total ethanol extract of C. chinensis at this dose.86 The LD50 of the total extract was 2950 mg/kg in rats, but it was 160–210 mg/kg for the alkaloid-enriched extract used in this study. Statistical significance was not reported. While berberine and total aqueous extract of C. chinensis rhizome both limited hepatic damage from carbon tetrachloride in male Sprague-Dawley rats, the total extract was more effective (statistical significance not stated).87 In a similar study, the aqueous rhizome extract and berberine had similar efficacy at preventing carbon tetrachloride liver damage in rats.88 The reason for the differences between these two studies is unknown, as the extracts and experimental designs were very similar.

The mixture of six parts C. chinensis and one part Tetradium rutaecarpa (evodia, wú zhū yú) fruit is known as Zuǒ Jīn Wán, “Left Metal Pill,” in Chinese medicine. It originated in 1481 CE in Dān Xī Xīn Fǎ (Essential Teachings of Dan-Xi) and is used to treat a wide range of digestive problems ranging from ulcers and esophageal reflux to nausea and vomiting. Administration of this formula to rats resulted in a complex pharmacokinetic interaction, notably an increase in absorption of major important compounds from T. rutaecarpa and a decrease in bioavailability of alkaloids from C. chinensis, notably coptisine and berberine.89,90 Pretreatment of rats with T. rutaecarpa fruit aqueous extract for 2 weeks also resulted in significant reduction in berberine bioavailability from C. chinensis.91 The mechanism appeared to be through the constituents of T. rutaecarpa inducing hepatic UGT1A1, increasing first pass metabolism of berberine. C. chinensis is commonly combined with T. rutaecarpa as a corrective assistant because C. chinensis is “cold” while T. rutaecarpa is “hot.”92 This pharmacokinetic outcome could be the desired result of the combination though it is difficult to be certain at this time.

One other line of evidence suggesting a balancing effect of these two herbs in combination comes from an in vitro study looking at the effects of C. chinensis and T. rutaecarpa separately and together on bovine adrenal medullary cells.93 The two herbs had diametrically opposed effects, with the alkaloids of C. chinensis inhibiting secretion from the cells and the alkaloids of T. rutaecarpa stimulating it. While this might suggest they simply cancel each other out and it would make little sense to combine them, it is more likely given the endurance of this herb pair in Chinese herbal medicine that the effect is balancing and beneficial in some way.

There are other hints in the literature that combining these two herbs as Zuǒ Jīn Wán may be superior to either alone. Evodiamine is an alkaloid found in T. rutaecarpa with multiple antineoplastic actions against gastric cancer cells in vitro, but it also increases IL-8 secretion by the cells, which is associated with increased risk of metastasis. Berberine blocked this effect.94 Berberine and evodiamine in combination were significantly better at inducing apoptosis in human hepatocellular carcinoma cells in vitro than either compound alone.95 All these results suggest a possible benefit of combining these two herbs in cancer patients.

Numerous lines of inquiry demonstrate synergistic and additive effects among and between medicinal herbs. Some of these are straightforward, and with multiple compounds with similar actions showing greater efficacy together than any one of them in isolation, such as the hypoglycemic activities of alkaloids in C. chinensis.16,17 Others are more subtle and complex; for instance, showing that compounds can indirectly enhance the efficacy of other compounds with direct effects, such as the methyloxylated flavonolignans in M. aquifolium leaf reducing resistance in Staphylococcus aureus to berberine in M. aquifolium root.9 Effects on pharmacokinetics between herbal compounds can be beneficially inhibitory (as in the case of the interaction between T. rutaecarpa and C. chinensis)2123 or enhancing (as is the case with G. uralensis and many compounds).78 Another type of synergy is reduction of toxicity of one herb by another, as demonstrated with G. uralensis and several very different types of herbs.62,71, 72

Further research is warranted to determine the extent and importance of these effects, particularly in humans, as much of the existing research is preclinical. Currently herbal medicine is still practiced by many practitioners based on the idea that these synergistic effects are relevant, as herbal formulas are still in widespread use. Further verifying that this approach is clinically useful and determining optimal formulations would be of great benefit to many patients around the globe.

  1. Samuelsson G.
    Drugs of Natural Origin: A Textbook of Pharmacognosy,
    4th edn.
    Stockholm:
    Apotekarsocieteten;
    1999.
  2. Evans WC.
    Trease and Evans’ Pharmacognosy,
    13th edn.
    London:
    Baillière Tindall;
    1989.
  3. Tran QL,
    Tezuka Y,
    Ueda JY, et al. In vitro antiplasmodial activity of antimalarial medicinal plants used in Vietnamese traditional medicine.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2003; 86(2–3):249–252.
  4. Wagner H.
    Synergy research: approaching a new generation of phytopharmatceuticals.
    Fitoterapia.
    2011; 82(1):34–37.
  5. Yarnell E.
    Artemisia annua (sweet Annie), other Artemisia species, artemisinin, artemisinin derivatives, and malaria.
    J Restorative Med.
    2014; 3(1):69–84.
  6. Mueller MS,
    Runyambo N,
    Wagner I, et al. Randomized controlled trial of a traditional preparation of Artemisia annua L (annual wormwood) in the treatment of malaria.
    Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
    2004; 98(5):318–321.
  7. Xie XY,
    Chen FF,
    Shi YP.
    Simultaneous determination of eight flavonoids in the flowers of Matricaria chamomilla by high performance liquid chromatography.
    J AOAC Int.
    2014; 97(3):778–783.
  8. Ezzat SM,
    Salama MM.
    A new α-glucosidase inhibitor from Achillea fragrantissima (Forssk) Sch Bip growing in Egypt.
    Nat Prod Res.
    2014; 28(11):812–818.
  9. Zhu XX,
    Yang L,
    Li YJ, et al.
    Effects of sesquiterpene, flavonoid and coumarin types of compounds from Artemisia annua L on production of mediators of angiogenesis.
    Pharmacol Rep.
    2013; 65(2):410–420.
  10. Kobayakawa J,
    Sato-Nishimori F,
    Moriyasu M,
    Matsukawa Y.
    G2-M arrest and antimitotic activity mediated by casticin, a flavonoid isolated from Viticis Fructus (Vitex rotundifolia Linne fil).
    Cancer Lett.
    2004; 208(1):59–64.
  11. Liu LP,
    Cao XC,
    Liu F, et al. Casticin induces breast cancer cell apoptosis by inhibiting the expression of forkhead box protein M1.
    Oncol Lett.
    2014; 7(5):1711–1717.
  12. Jiang L,
    Cao XC,
    Cao JG, et al. Casticin induces ovarian cancer cell apoptosis by repressing FoxM1 through the activation of FOXO3a.
    Oncol Lett.
    2013; 5(5):1605–1610.
  13. Ono M,
    Yanaka T,
    Yamamoto M, et al. New diterpenes and norditerpenes from the fruits of Vitex rotundifolia.
    J Nat Prod.
    2002; 65(4):537–541.
  14. Yang J,
    Yang Y,
    Tian L, et al.
    Casticin-induced apoptosis involves death receptor 5 upregulation in hepatocellular carcinoma cells.
    World J Gastroenterol.
    2011; 17(38):4298–4307.
  15. Ye Q,
    Zhang QY,
    Zheng CJ, et al.
    Casticin, a flavonoid isolated from Vitex rotundifolia, inhibits prolactin release in vivo and in vitro.
    Acta Pharmacol Sin.
    2010; 31(12):1564–1568.
  16. Lim EK,
    Mitchell PJ,
    Brown N, et al.
    Regiospecific methylation of a dietary flavonoid scaffold selectively enhances IL-1β production following Toll-like receptor 2 stimulation in THP-1 monocytes.
    J Biol Chem.
    2013; 288(29):21126–21135.
  17. Liou CJ,
    Len WB,
    Wu SJ, et al.
    Casticin inhibits COX-2 and iNOS expression via suppression of NF-κB and MAPK signaling in lipopolysaccharide-stimulated mouse macrophages.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2014; 158PA:310–316.
  18. Choudhary MI,
    Azizuddin ,
    Jalil S, et al.
    Antiinflammatory and lipoxygenase inhibitory compounds from Vitex agnus-castus.
    Phytother Res.
    2009; 23(9):1336–1339.
  19. Sertié JA,
    Basile AC,
    Panizza S, et al.
    Anti-inflammatory activity and sub-acute toxicity of artemetin.
    Planta Med.
    1990; 56(1):36–40.
  20. Michielin EM,
    Salvador AA,
    Riehl CA, et al.
    Chemical composition and antibacterial activity of Cordia verbenacea extracts obtained by different methods.
    Bioresour Technol.
    2009; 100(24):6615–6623.
  21. de Souza P,
    Gasparotto A Jr,
    Crestani S, et al.
    Hypotensive mechanism of the extracts and artemetin isolated from Achillea millefolium L (Asteraceae) in rats.
    Phytomedicine.
    2011; 18(10):819–825.
  22. Sridevi VK,
    Chouhan HS,
    Singh NK,
    Singh SK.
    Antioxidant and hepatoprotective effects of ethanol extract of Vitex glabrata on carbon tetrachloride-induced liver damage in rats.
    Nat Prod Res.
    2012; 26(12):1135–1140.
  23. Dugas AJ Jr,
    Castañeda-Acosta J,
    Bonin GC, et al.
    Evaluation of the total peroxyl radical-scavenging capacity of flavonoids: structure-activity relationships.
    J Nat Prod.
    2000; 63(3):327–331.
  24. Ortet R,
    Prado S,
    Regalado EL, et al. Furfuran lignans and a flavone from Artemisia gorgonum Webb and their in vitro activity against Plasmodium falciparum.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2011; 138(2):637–640.
  25. Elford BC,
    Roberts MF,
    Phillipson JD,
    Wilson RJ.
    Potentiation of the antimalarial activity of qinghaosu by methoxylated flavones.
    Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
    1987; 81(3):434–436.
  26. Liu KCS,
    Yang SY,
    Roberts MF, et al. The contribution of flavonoids to the antimalarial activity of Artemisia annua.
    Planta Med.
    1989; 55(7):654–655.
  27. Liu KC,
    Yang SL,
    Roberts MF, et al. Antimalarial activity of Artemisia annua flavonoids from whole plants and cell cultures.
    Plant Cell Rep.
    1992; 11(12):637–640.
  28. Weathers PJ,
    Towler MJ.
    The flavonoids casticin and artemetin are poorly extracted and are unstable in an Artemisia annua tea infusion.
    Planta Med.
    2012; 78(10):1024–1026.
  29. Ferreira JF,
    Peaden P,
    Keiser J.
    In vitro trematocidal effects of crude alcoholic extracts of Artemisia annua, A. absinthium, Asimina triloba, and Fumaria officinalis: trematocidal plant alcoholic extracts.
    Parasitol Res.
    2011; 109(6):1585–1592.
  30. Mouton J,
    Jansen O,
    Frédérich M,
    van der Kooy F.
    Is artemisinin the only antiplasmodial compound in the Artemisia annua tea infusion? An in vitro study.
    Planta Med.
    2013; 79(6):468–470.
  31. Wright CW,
    Linley PA,
    Brun R, et al. Ancient Chinese methods are remarkably effective for the preparation of artemisinin-rich extracts of Qing Hao with potent antimalarial activity.
    Molecules.
    2010; 15(2):804–812.
  32. Wan YD,
    Zang QZ,
    Wang JS.
    Studies on the antimalarial action of gelatin capsule of Artemisia annua.
    Zhongguo Ji Sheng Chong Xue Yu Ji Sheng Chong Bing Za Zhi.
    1992; 10(4):290–294 [in Chinese].
  33. De Donno A,
    Grassi T,
    Idolo A, et al. First-time comparison of the in vitro antimalarial activity of Artemisia annua herbal tea and artemisinin.
    Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg.
    2012; 106(11):696–700.
  34. Favero F de F,
    Grando R,
    Nonato FR, et al. Artemisia annua L: evidence of sesquiterpene lactones’ fraction antinociceptive activity.
    BMC Complement Altern Med.
    2014; 14:266.
  35. Huang L,
    Liu JF,
    Liu LX, et al.
    Antipyretic and anti-inflammatory effects of Artemisia annua L.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi 1993; 18:44–48,
    63–64 [in Chinese].
  36. Melillo de Magalhães P,
    Dupont I,
    Hendrickx A, et al.
    Anti-inflammatory effect and modulation of cytochrome P450 activities by Artemisia annua tea infusions in human intestinal Caco-2 cells.
    Food Chem.
    2012; 134(2):864–871.
  37. Stermitz FR,
    Scriven LN,
    Tegos G,
    Lewis K.
    Two flavonols from Artemisa annua which potentiate the activity of berberine and norfloxacin against a resistant strain of Staphylococcus aureus.
    Planta Med.
    2002; 68(12):1140–1141.
  38. Rasoanaivo P,
    Wright CW,
    Willcox ML,
    Gilbert B.
    Whole plant extracts versus single compounds for the treatment of malaria: synergy and positive interactions.
    Malar J.
    2011; 10(Suppl 1):S4.
  39. Gathirwa JW,
    Rukunga GM,
    Njagi EN, et al.
    The in vitro anti-plasmodial and in vivo anti-malarial efficacy of combinations of some medicinal plants used traditionally for treatment of malaria by the Meru community in Kenya.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2008; 115(2):223–231.
  40. Eder M,
    Mehnert W.
    Plant excipients–valuable pharmaceutical aids or superfluous ballast?
    Pharm Unserer Zeit.
    2000; 29(6):377–384 [in German].
  41. Haug KG,
    Weber B,
    Hochhaus G,
    Butterweck V.
    Pharmacokinetic evaluation of visnagin and Ammi visnaga aqueous extract after oral administration in rats.
    Planta Med.
    2012; 78(17):1831–1836.
  42. Schimmer O,
    Rauch P.
    Inhibition of metabolic activation of the promutagens, benzo[a]pyrene, 2-aminofluorene and 2-aminoanthracene by furanochromones in Salmonella typhimurium.
    Mutagenesis.
    1998; 13(4):385–389.
  43. Vanachayangkul P,
    Chow N,
    Khan SR,
    Butterweck V.
    Prevention of renal crystal deposition by an extract of Ammi visnaga L and its constituents khellin and visnagin in hyperoxaluric rats.
    Urol Res.
    2011; 39(3):189–195.
  44. Vanachayangkul P,
    Byer K,
    Khan S,
    Butterweck V.
    An aqueous extract of Ammi visnaga fruits and its constituents khellin and visnagin prevent cell damage caused by oxalate in renal epithelial cells.
    Phytomedicine.
    2010; 17(8–9):653–658.
  45. Xie S,
    Zhang G,
    Sun G, et al.
    Detoxication experimental study on different compatibility proportion of Aconiti Lateralis Radix Praeparata and glycyrrhizae radix et rhizoma.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi.
    2012; 37(15):2210–2214 [in Chinese].
  46. Li Y,
    Fu CM,
    Ren B, et al.
    Study on attenuate and synergistic mechanism between aconiti lateralis praeparata radix and glycyrrhizae radix for toxicity reduction based on metabonomic of MI-RI mouse cardiomyocytes.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi.
    2014; 39(16):3166–3171 [in Chinese].
  47. Zhao MQ,
    Wu WK,
    Zhao DY, et al.
    Protective effects of sini decoction on adriamycin-induced heart failure and its mechanism.
    Zhong Yao Cai.
    2009; 32(12):1860–1863 [in Chinese].
  48. Liu J,
    Peter K,
    Shi D, et al.
    Traditional formula, modern application: Chinese medicine formula sini tang improves early ventricular remodeling and cardiac function after myocardial infarction in rats.
    Evid Based Complement Alternat Med.
    2014; 2014:141938.
  49. Zhang G,
    Zhu L,
    Zhou J, et al.
    Effect of aconiti laterlis radix compatibility of glycyrrhizae radix on CYP3A4 in vivo.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi.
    2012; 37(15):2206–2209 [in Chinese].
  50. Shen H,
    Wu J,
    Di LQ, et al.
    Enhancement by Glycyrrhizae Radix of hepatic metabolism of hypaconitine, a major bioactive and toxic component of Aconiti Laterlis Radix, evaluated by HPLC-TQ-MS/MS analysis.
    Biomed Chromatogr.
    2013; 27(5):556–562.
  51. Zhang JM,
    Li L,
    Gao F, et al.
    Chemical ingredient analysis of sediments from both single Radix Aconiti Lateralis decoction and Radix Aconiti Lateralis – Radix Glycyrrhizae decoction by HPLC-MS.
    Yao Xue Xue Bao.
    2012; 47(11):1527–1533 [in Chinese].
  52. Yang Y,
    Yin XJ,
    Guo HM, et al.
    Identification and comparative analysis of the major chemical constituents in the extracts of single fuzi herb and fuzi-gancao herb-pair by UFLC-IT-TOF/MS.
    Chin J Nat Med.
    2014; 12(7):542–453.
  53. Zhang W,
    Zhang H,
    Sun S, et al.
    Comparative pharmacokinetics of hypaconitine after oral administration of pure hypaconitine, Aconitum carmichaelii extract and sini decoction to rats.
    Molecules.
    2015; 20(1):1560–1570.
  54. Ma L.
    Studies on the Changes of the Main Compounds in Co-boiling Extracts, Pooled Individual Boiling Extracts in Dioscorea bulbifera L and Glycyrrhiza uralensis Fisch Decoction (Thesis, Fujian University of Traditional Chinese Medicine),
    2011.
  55. Li YS,
    Tong PJ,
    Ma HZ.
    Toxicity attenuation and efficacy potentiation effect of liquorice on treatment of rheumatoid arthritis with Tripterygium wilfordii.
    Zhongguo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za Zhi.
    2006; 26(12):1117–1119 [in Chinese].
  56. Wang X,
    Zhang H,
    Chen L, et al.
    Liquorice, a unique ‘guide drug’ of traditional Chinese medicine: a review of its role in drug interactions.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2013; 150(3):781–790.
  57. Nie RL,
    Tanaka T,
    Miyakoshi M, et al.
    A triterpenoid saponin from Thladiantha hookeri var pentadactyla.
    Phytochemistry.
    1989; 28(6):1711–1715.
  58. Wantanabe K,
    Fujino H,
    Morita T, et al.
    Solubilization of saponins of bupleuri radix with ginseng saponins: cooperative effect of dammarane saponins.
    Planta Med.
    1988; 54(5):405–409.
  59. Kimata H,
    Sumida N,
    Matsufuji N, et al.
    Interaction of saponin of bupleuri radix with ginseng saponin: solubilization of saikosaponin-a with chikusetsusaponin-V (=ginsenoside Ro).
    Chem Pharm Bull.
    1985; 33(7):2849–2853.
  60. Zhou X,
    Kasai R,
    Yoshikawa M, et al.
    Solubilization of saponins of Bupleuri radix with Ginseng saponins: effect of malonyl-ginsenosides on water solubility of saikosaponin-b.
    Chem Pharm Bull.
    1991; 39(5):1250–1252.
  61. Guo J,
    Shang E,
    Zhao J, et al.
    Data mining and frequency analysis for licorice as a ‘two-face’ herb in Chinese formulae based on Chinese Formulae Database.
    Phytomedicine.
    2014; 21(11):1281–1286.
  62. Chen L,
    Yang J,
    Davey AK, et al.
    Effects of diammonium glycyrrhizinate on the pharmacokinetics of aconitine in rats and the potential mechanism.
    Xenobiotica.
    2009; 39(12):955–963.
  63. Nabekura T,
    Hiro T,
    Kawasaki T,
    Uwai Y.
    Effects of natural nuclear factor-kappa B inhibitors on anticancer drug efflux transporter human P-glycoprotein.
    Biomed Pharmacother.
    2015; 70:140–145.
  64. Bhattacharjee A,
    Majumder S,
    Majumdar SB, et al.
    Co-administration of glycyrrhizic acid with the antileishmanial drug sodium antimony gluconate (SAG) cures SAG-resistant visceral leishmaniasis.
    Int J Antimicrob Agents.
    2015; 45(3):268–277.
  65. Cao J,
    Chen X,
    Liang J, et al.
    Role of P-glycoprotein in the intestinal absorption of glabridin, an active flavonoid from the root of Glycyrrhiza glabra.
    Drug Metab Dispos.
    2007; 35(4):539–553.
  66. Yao HW,
    Fu XY,
    Xie QD, et al.
    Effect of liquorice decoction on rat intestinal P-glycoprotein.
    Nan Fang Yi Ke Da Xue Xue Bao.
    2009; 29(8):1571–1573 [in Chinese].
  67. Zhang J,
    Zhou F,
    Wu X, et al.
    20(S)-Ginsenoside Rh2 noncompetitively inhibits P-glycoprotein in vitro and in vivo: a case for herb-drug interactions.
    Drug Metab Dispos.
    2010; 38(12):2179–2187.
  68. Huang BB,
    Li GF,
    Ren F, et al.
    Effect of Glycyrrhiza inflata and Daphne genkwa on permeabilities of rhodamine 123, a P-glycoprotein substrate across rat jejunum membranes in vitro.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi.
    2008; 33(21):2521–2526 [in Chinese].
  69. Sun YB,
    Li GF,
    Tang ZK,
    Wu BY.
    Modulation on the P-glycoprotein in the jejunum by combined use of Glycyrrhiza inflata and kansui.
    Yao Xue Xue Bao.
    2010; 45(4):510–516 [in Chinese].
  70. Shen J,
    Mo X,
    Tang Y, et al.
    Analysis of herb-herb interaction when decocting together by using ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry and fuzzy chemical identification strategy with poly-proportion design.
    J Chromatogr A.
    2013; 1297:168–178.
  71. Cantelli-Forti G,
    Maffei F,
    Hrelia P, et al.
    Interaction of licorice on glycyrrhizin pharmacokinetics.
    Environ Health Perspect.
    1994; 102(suppl 9):65–68.
  72. Wang Z,
    Nishioka M,
    Kurosaki Y, et al.
    Gastrointestinal absorption characteristics of glycyrrhizin from Glycyrrhiza extract.
    Biol Pharm Bull.
    1995; 18(9):1238–1241.
  73. Kamei J,
    Saitoh A,
    Asano T, et al.
    Pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic profiles of the antitussive principles of Glycyrrhizae radix (licorice), a main component of the Kampo preparation Bakumondo-to (Mai-men-dong-tang).
    Eur J Pharmacol.
    2005; 507(1–3):163–168.
  74. Zani F,
    Cuzzoni MT,
    Daglia M, et al.
    Inhibition of mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium by Glycyrrhiza glabra extract, glycyrrhizinic acid, 18α- and 18β-glycyrrhetinic acids.
    Planta Med.
    1993; 59(6):502–507.
  75. Kobayashi S,
    Miyamoto T,
    Kimura I,
    Kimura M.
    Inhibitory effect of isoliquiritin, a compound in licorice root, on angiogenesis in vivo and tube formation in vitro.
    Biol Pharm Bull.
    1995; 18(10):1382–1386.
  76. Feng YC,
    Wang KC,
    Chiang LC, et al.
    Water extract of licorice had anti-viral activity against human respiratory syncytial virus in human respiratory tract cell lines.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2013; 148(2):466–473.
  77. Stermitz FR,
    Lorenz P,
    Tawara JN, et al.
    Synergy in a medicinal plant: antimicrobial action of berberine potentiated by 5’-methoxyhydnocarpin, a multidrug pump inhibitor.
    Proc Natl Acad Sci.
    2000; 97(4):1433–1437.
  78. Stermitz FR,
    Tawara-Matsuda J,
    Lorenz P, et al.
    5’-Methoxyhydnocarpin-D and pheophorbide a: Berberis species components that potentiate berberine growth inhibition of resistant Staphylococcus aureus.
    J Nat Prod.
    2000; 63(8):1146–1149.
  79. Stermitz FR,
    Beeson TD,
    Mueller PJ, et al. Staphylococcus aureus MDR efflux pump inhibitors from a Berberis and a Mahonia (sensu strictu) species.
    Biochem Syst Ecol.
    2001; 29(8):793–798.
  80. Musumeci R,
    Speciale A,
    Costanzo R, et al. Berberis aetnensis C Presl extracts: antimicrobial properties and interaction with ciprofloxacin.
    Int J Antimicrob Agents.
    2003; 22(1):48–53.
  81. Ivanovska N,
    Philipov S.
    Study on the anti-inflammatory action of Berberis vulgaris root extract, alkaloid fractions and pure alkaloids.
    Int J Immunopharmacol.
    1996; 18(10):553–561.
  82. Iauk L,
    Costanzo R,
    Caccamo F, et al.
    Activity of Berberis aetnensis root extracts on Candida strains.
    Fitoterapia.
    2007; 78(2):159–161.
  83. Chen HY,
    Ye XL,
    Cui XL, et al.
    Cytotoxicity and antihyperglycemic effect of minor constituents from Rhizoma Coptis in HepG2 cells.
    Fitoterapia.
    2012; 83(1):67–73.
  84. Zhu J,
    Xin FQ,
    Chen X, et al.
    Synergism of alkaloids from Coptis Rhizoma.
    Shi Zhen Med Mater Med Res.
    2010; 21:2282–2284 [in Chinese].
  85. Yi J,
    Ye X,
    Wang D, et al.
    Safety evaluation of main alkaloids from Rhizoma Coptidis.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2013; 145(1):303–310.
  86. Ma BL,
    Ma YM,
    Shi R, et al.
    Identification of the toxic constituents in Rhizoma Coptidis.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2010; 128(2):357–364.
  87. Feng Y,
    Wang N,
    Ye X, et al.
    Hepatoprotective effect and its possible mechanism of Coptidis rhizoma aqueous extract on carbon tetrachloride-induced chronic liver hepatotoxicity in rats.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2011; 138(3):683–690.
  88. Ye X,
    Feng Y,
    Tong Y, et al.
    Hepatoprotective effects of Coptidis rhizoma aqueous extract on carbon tetrachloride-induced acute liver hepatotoxicity in rats.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2009; 124(1):130–136.
  89. Yan R,
    Wang Y,
    Shen W, et al.
    Comparative pharmacokinetics of dehydroevodiamine and coptisine in rat plasma after oral administration of single herbs and Zuojinwan prescription.
    Fitoterapia.
    2011; 82(8):1152–1159.
  90. Jia X,
    Jiang J,
    Chen B, et al.
    Progress in research of processing of fructus Evodiae-Rhizoma Coptidis and research thoughts and methods of its processing mechanism.
    Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi.
    2009; 34(10):1314–1317 [in Chinese].
  91. Ma BL,
    Yao MK,
    Han XH, et al.
    Influences of Fructus evodiae pretreatment on the pharmacokinetics of Rhizoma coptidis alkaloids.
    J Ethnopharmacol.
    2011; 137(3):1395–1401.
  92. Dharmananda S.
    Evodia: Traditional and Modern Uses.
    Institute for Traditional Medicine,
    Portland, OR.
    http://www.itmonline.org/articles/evodia/evodia.htm [accessed 19 Feb 2015] ,
    2010.
  93. Zhao FR,
    Mao HP,
    Zhang H, et al.
    Antagonistic effects of two herbs in Zuojin Wan, a traditional Chinese medicine formula, on catecholamine secretion in bovine adrenal medullary cells.
    Phytomedicine.
    2010; 17(8–9):659–668.
  94. Shi HL,
    Wu XJ,
    Liu Y,
    Xie JQ.
    Berberine counteracts enhanced IL-8 expression of AGS cells induced by evodiamine.
    Life Sci.
    2013; 93(22):830–839.
  95. Wang XN,
    Han X,
    Xu LN, et al.
    Enhancement of apoptosis of human hepatocellular carcinoma SMMC-7721 cells through synergy of berberine and evodiamine.
    Phytomedicine.
    2008; 15(12):1062–1068.

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.14200/jrm.2015.4.0104

You can also access full issues of the Journal of Restorative Medicine here.